The Effects of Advertising Disclosure Regulations on Social Media: Evidence from Instagram
RAND Journal of Economics, 56(1), 74-90.
Abstract
We study the effects of advertising disclosure regulations in social media markets using Instagram data from Germany and Spain and a difference-in-differences approach. The German strengthening of disclosure rules increased the use of disclosure terms, but also increased sponsored content by 12% and raised the share of undisclosed sponsored content consumers were exposed to. We also find reductions in engagement, suggesting that followers were likely negatively affected.
Main Finding
Disclosure rules increased disclosure, but they also increased sponsored content by 12% and raised consumers' exposure to undisclosed sponsored posts.
Policy Relevance
Disclosure regulation can change the supply of sponsored content, not only labeling compliance; this matters for consumer-protection policy on social media.
Notes
- Extended abstract published in the ACM-EC 2020 Conference Proceedings.
See Also
- [Paper]Frontiers: How Much Influencer Marketing Is Undisclosed? Evidence from Twitter
- [Policy]The Majority of Influencer Advertising Is Undisclosed
- [Paper]Interaction of Spectrum Auctions and Mobile Market Competition: Review of Theory and Evidence from European 4G Auctions
- [Paper]Expansion of Influencer Advertising: Evidence from the NCAA NIL Policy
- [Policy]Pricing Algorithms as Third-Party Facilitators of Collusion
- [Paper]Sharing News Left and Right: Frictions and Misinformation on Twitter
- [Paper]Algorithmic Pricing and Competition: Empirical Evidence from the German Retail Gasoline Market
- [Policy]Algorithmic Pricing and Competition